Welcome! I’m Simon Owens and this is my media industry newsletter. If you’ve received it, then you either subscribed or someone forwarded it to you.
If you fit into the latter camp and want to subscribe, then you can click on this handy little button:
Let’s jump into it…
Quick hits
1: A writer for Defector wonders why The Ringer is publishing paywalled articles to Substack instead of simply hosting them behind a paywall on its own website. [Defector]
My answer? For the same reason Defector hosts its video podcasts on YouTube instead of simply uploading them to its own website — it recognizes there’s a huge audience ecosystem on YouTube that would rather watch videos there than click back to its site. Creating standalone native content for Substack is not all that different from publishers creating videos for Instagram Reels or TikTok. It’s a recognition that fewer and fewer people are clicking on links and sometimes it’s better to bring your content to where the audiences are. Plus, if this experiment doesn’t work out, The Ringer can simply export its email lists and move its Stripe accounts back to its website.
2: Spotify delivered another strong earnings report, but it continues to struggle to grow its advertising business despite having an enormous audience of free users. [Bloomberg] (I used a gift link so you can access the article for free.)
Why is Spotify having such a hard time? My theory is that audio advertising is much harder to scale across platforms than display or video advertising. A brand can create a display ad once and run it across millions of websites. The same goes for video ads, which can be repurposed for Facebook, TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, thousands of websites, and a growing number of streaming TV services.
Audio ads, on the other hand, have far fewer places to run at scale. Spotify is one of the only digital platforms with a truly massive audio audience. Beyond that, advertisers can buy inventory through a handful of podcast ad networks, but many podcasts still require individual negotiations. And I suspect most brands advertising on Spotify aren’t particularly interested in terrestrial radio.
As a result, producing an audio-only ad requires a much bigger commitment from an advertiser, especially when that ad can’t be easily repurposed across dozens of other platforms.
Then there’s the fact that Spotify’s paying subscribers — arguably the users advertisers would most want to reach — are largely enjoying an ad-free experience. Put all these factors together, and it’s not hard to see why Spotify faces such an uphill battle in building its advertising business.
3: Disney+ got the memo that it was making too many Marvel shows, but for some reason it didn’t replace those shows with other kinds of new content. As The Ringer put it, “That diminished Disney+ output reflects a wider downsizing across the streaming landscape—but also, perhaps, an overcorrection to an overcorrection by a service that’s searching for a happy medium in the speed of its streaming assembly line.” [The Ringer]
In fact, I can’t really even remember the last time a show on the platform had any real buzz. Maybe Andor? Oh wait — now that I think of it, I did watch and mostly enjoy Wonder Man, which didn’t get renewed. A weird move for Disney considering so many of its other Marvel shows were critical duds.
Yes, I know that Disney+ is in the middle of an awkward merging with Hulu — which continues to produce some hit programming like Furious, which was also technically viewable in the Disney+ app — but there are still not a lot of reasons to go to Disney+ specifically, and there haven’t been in a long time.
What do you think?
(when you vote you’ll see the results)
How the Kyiv Independent used global sympathy to generate membership revenue
The Kyiv Independent launched in 2021, and its timing was in some ways fortuitous, since it was only a few months later that Russia launched a full-scale invasion in Ukraine. Suddenly, the entire world was paying attention to the country, and the Kyiv Independent happened to be the most authoritative English-language outlet to be reporting on the ground. This attention not only resulted in a massive amount of traffic, but also a surge in membership donations as sympathetic Westerners sought out ways to support Ukraine’s cause.
In a recent interview, Chief Operating Officer Zakhar Protsiuk discussed the early days of getting the Kyiv Independent off the ground, its shift from one-time donations to recurring memberships, and why the outlet has begun producing longform documentaries.
You can check out the interview over here.
REMINDER: I’m building the world’s largest library of media entrepreneur case studies
I’ve made it my goal to build the world’s largest database of media case studies. I seek out the most successful media entrepreneurs and interview them about how they built their businesses, step by step. With every case study you walk away with actionable insights that you can incorporate into your own content operations.
It doesn’t matter if you’re a YouTuber, podcaster, newsletter writer, or traditional news publisher — you’re going to find strategies here that you can incorporate into your own business.
So far, I’ve amassed a library of 146 case studies and plan to add to it each month.
Paid subscribers can access the entire index of case studies over here.
Want to read these case studies without subscribing?
I get it. We’re all succumbing to subscription fatigue, and not everyone is eager to take out their credit card and sign up for yet another monthly payment.
Luckily, I packaged these case studies into an ebook spanning 882 pages and over 300,000 words. I’m pretty confident there isn’t another book on the market that’s packed with this many insights for how to build a successful content business.
It’s available in both PDF and epub formats.
You can purchase the ebook over here.



You’re on base for Spotify. I work for the streaming service Audiomack. Despite outrageous demand for audio ads, the supply is scant—especially outside the US. Nearly all efforts are for display. I wonder if someone could create an AI platform to convert a visual ad to audio that brands would accept.
Your explanation on The Ringer doesn’t ring true. As a long time daily use of Ringer it doesn’t make sense. They publish all the other articles right on their site and have done since inception. It creates friction so I literally don’t click to read Zack Lowe. I suspect the real reason is for Lowe to put one large foot out of the Ringer bus.